The proposal to construct two high-rises, 26 stories and 23 stories, on College Avenue where Trader Joe’s is now, continues.
Earlier this year Rockridge residents were heartened when the Rockridge Community Planning Council (RCPC) posted on its site that it was surprised by the scale of the project and would be advocating for a project “that contributes to our pedestrian-oriented neighborhood and sustains the commercial and social vitality of College Avenue, without overwhelming it.”
It seemed to indicate opposition. RCPC’s own survey results showed overwhelming opposition from the community. Granted, there was no big announcement to the public (you had to search hard to find the statement), but it did look like RCPC would do its best to oppose the project. It established a subcommittee to contact Align, the developer…Align is also the developer of the monster skyscraper proposed at the San Francisco Marina Safeway.

The RCPC Board has had two private meetings with Align and has not publicly disclosed what happened. The sub-committee had one meeting October 23rd and will be meeting with Align soon, a meeting at which some would like the senior living operator to also be present, but which has not been confirmed.
The composition of the committee so far is not promising. Only two representatives are openly opposed to the towers, one from Upper Broadway Advocates and one from Rockridge Neighbors for Sensible Housing. The rest are mostly RCPC members known for their staunchly pro-development stance. One member stated he would be happy to see high-rises up and down College Avenue.


Other members hope to squeeze out mitigations, such as wider sidewalks, better garbage collection, deeper setbacks, traffic controls, overall aesthetics, etc. When it meets with Align, will it convey the overwhelming public opposition to the project? Will it take the role that the Marina folks opposed to the high-rise took by publicly opposing the entire project? Will it seek the intervention of Mayor Lee and Assembly Member Buffy Wicks? Clearly not. RCPC will do its best to make the project “nicer,” but it has no intention of publicly opposing the towers.
Note that UBA requested a meeting with Align and never received an answer; Note that Oaklandside and the Oakland Report have not covered the issue, and a Chronicle article charged Rockridge residents as being aging NIMBYs defending their turf.
UBA is a small group. We organized along with RNSH a meeting in July attended by 300 people, overwhelming hostile to the towers. We have advised the City that in an earthquake, the higher the building the greater the sway and the number of frail persons who will fall and be injured.
Given that elevators will shut down, how will hundreds of the elderly descend 25 stories? This health and safety issue alone should be enough to stop the towers.
Those who hope that the towers will build a new Trader Joe’s to replace the old should understand that that is very unlikely. Underground parking would be required. Seventy-five spaces, $100,000 each, would be required, a price unlikely to be feasible. And again, why would Safeway who owns the property, install a competitor, unless the property is sold to the senior living operator? The Trader Joe issue is likely a ploy to calm the community, not a serious proposal.
UBA will continue its opposition. We have already asked our followers to send letters to the City and Assembly Member Wicks, and will continue to do so.
To volunteer to actively work to oppose the project, let us know at Ubaoakland@gmail.com. To stay informed and continue to oppose, sign up at UBAOakland.org. And, let RCPC know how you feel by sending a letter to landuse@rockridge.org.